Shelter Island, NY Apartments & Houses For Rent

price
-
1-4 of 4 Homes
$40,000 | 3 Lakeview Drive | Shelter Island
$40,000

3 Lakeview Drive
Shelter Island, NY 11964

4
Beds
2
1,720
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Mackenzie Needham
$28,000 | 26 Ole Buck Run | Shelter Island Heights
$28,000

26 Ole Buck Run
Shelter Island, NY 11964

3
Beds
2
1,238
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Debra L. Von Brook Binder CBR
$30,000 | 104 South Ferry Road | Shelter Island
$30,000

104 South Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964

5
Beds
6
4,040
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Debra L. Von Brook Binder CBR
$75,000 | 15 Montclair Avenue | Shelter Island Heights
$75,000

15 Montclair Avenue
Shelter Island, NY 11964

6
Beds
5
4,600
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Corcoran, Margot Reutter

To view more listings near Shelter Island, try one of these:

Similar homes within 4 miles

$215,000 | 15 Ezekillis Hollow | North Haven
Compass Coming Soon
$215,000

15 Ezekillis Hollow
Sag Harbor, NY 11963

5
Beds
6
5,100
Sq. Ft.
$4,000 | 8 Oyster Point | Greenport
$4,000

8 Oyster Point
Greenport, NY 11944

2
Beds
2
1,190
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Town And Country Real Estate, Jean Marie Bay
$22,000 | 130 6th Street | Greenport
$22,000

130 6th Street
Greenport, NY 11944

5
Beds
2
2,600
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Town And Country Real Estate, Lori Feilen
$50,000 | 131 6th Street, Unit 7 | Greenport West
$50,000

131 6th Street, Unit 7
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
3
2,238
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Alexis Meadows ABR
$125,000 | 1 Fox Crossing | North Haven
$125,000

1 Fox Crossing
Sag Harbor, NY 11963

5
Beds
5
5,500
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
$5,000 | 446 6th Street | Greenport
$5,000

446 6th Street
Greenport, NY 11944

4
Beds
2
1,400
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Paul Loeb CBR
$2,600 | 513 5th Street | Greenport
$2,600

513 5th Street
Greenport, NY 11944

1
Bed
1
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Paul Loeb CBR
$70,000 | 9 Blue Heron Way | North Haven
$70,000

9 Blue Heron Way
North Haven, NY 11963

5
Beds
7
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$18,000 | 905 9th Street | Greenport West
$18,000

905 9th Street
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
3
1,800
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Alexander Aquino
$12,000 | 412 Carpenter Street | Greenport
Listed By Compass
$12,000

412 Carpenter Street
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
2
1,400
Sq. Ft.
$4,000 | 719 Wiggins Street | Greenport West
$4,000

719 Wiggins Street
Greenport, NY 11944

2
Beds
2
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Richmond Realty Corp, Isaac D. Israel; Richmond Realty Corp, Amanda L. Capobianco CBR
$15,000 | 231 5th Avenue | Greenport
$15,000

231 5th Avenue
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
2
2,296
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Alexander Aquino
$3,500 | 711 Front Street | Greenport West
$3,500

711 Front Street
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
2
1,700
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, William J. Walters CBR
$18,000 | 123 Sterling Avenue, Unit 12 | Greenport
$18,000

123 Sterling Avenue, Unit 12
Greenport, NY 11944

2
Beds
4
2,253
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, William J. Walters CBR
$3,200 | 248 5th Avenue | Greenport
$3,200

248 5th Avenue
Greenport, NY 11944

1
Bed
1
1,306
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Peter D. Halpin
$2,000 | 1000 9th Street, Unit J73 | Greenport West
$2,000

1000 9th Street, Unit J73
Greenport, NY 11944

1
Bed
1
750
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Paul Loeb CBR
$5,750 | 417 West Street | Greenport
$5,750

417 West Street
Greenport, NY 11944

4
Beds
2
1,740
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Apollo Point Realty LLC, Jensen Ambachen
$3,500 | 324 5th Avenue | Greenport
$3,500

324 5th Avenue
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
2
1,600
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, JoAnn Wind
$15,000 | 165 Sterling Street | Greenport
New
$15,000

165 Sterling Street
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
2
1,700
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate, Mitchell Pickman CBR
$3,900 | 630 1st Street | Greenport
$3,900

630 1st Street
Greenport, NY 11944

2
Beds
1
1,050
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Kenneth D. Poliwoda CBR; Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Barbara J. Poliwoda
$14,500 | 1545 Pipes Neck Road | Greenport West
$14,500

1545 Pipes Neck Road
Greenport, NY 11944

4
Beds
2
1,500
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Rene A. Giacobbe
$225,000 | 33 Robertson Drive | North Haven
Compass Coming Soon
$225,000

33 Robertson Drive
Sag Harbor, NY 11963

7
Beds
9
6,500
Sq. Ft.
$20,000 | 950 Blue Marlin Drive | Greenport West
$20,000

950 Blue Marlin Drive
Southold, NY 11971

4
Beds
4
3,200
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Town And Country Real Estate, Lori Feilen
$4,500 | 220 Fiddler Lane | Greenport West
$4,500

220 Fiddler Lane
Greenport, NY 11944

3
Beds
1
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Rita M. Rooney
$85,000 | 165 Marine Place | Greenport West
$85,000

165 Marine Place
Greenport, NY 11944

4
Beds
5
3,800
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Paul Loeb CBR
$3,100 | 235 Bridge Street | Greenport West
Listed By Compass
$3,100

235 Bridge Street
Greenport, NY 11944

1
Bed
1
1,000
Sq. Ft.
$13,500 | 155 Bridge Street | Greenport West
$13,500

155 Bridge Street
Greenport, NY 11944

5
Beds
4
2,400
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, William J. Walters CBR
$50,000 | 10 Maunakea Street | North Haven
Listed By Compass
$50,000

10 Maunakea Street
Sag Harbor, NY 11963

4
Beds
3
2,128
Sq. Ft.
$12,000 | 370 South Lane | East Marion
$12,000

370 South Lane
East Marion, NY 11939

4
Beds
4
3,000
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, JoAnn Wind
$4,000 | 1425 Paradise Point Road | Southold
Listed By Compass
$4,000

1425 Paradise Point Road
Southold, NY 11971

3
Beds
2
1,650
Sq. Ft.
$6,000 | 1935 Old Orchard Road | East Marion
$6,000

1935 Old Orchard Road
East Marion, NY 11939

2
Beds
1
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Rita M. Rooney
$12,600 | 2395 Bay Avenue | East Marion
$12,600

2395 Bay Avenue
East Marion, NY 11939

3
Beds
3
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Corcoran, Sheri Winter Parker
$22,500 | 75 Gillette Drive | East Marion
$22,500

75 Gillette Drive
East Marion, NY 11939

6
Beds
5
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, William J. Walters CBR
$11,000 | 2085 Bay Avenue | East Marion
$11,000

2085 Bay Avenue
East Marion, NY 11939

2
Beds
1
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Corcoran, Sheri Winter Parker
$5,000 | 455 West Shore Drive | Southold
$5,000

455 West Shore Drive
Southold, NY 11971

4
Beds
3
1,625
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Corcoran, Eric Frend
$8,500 | 295 Rabbit Lane | East Marion
$8,500

295 Rabbit Lane
East Marion, NY 11939

3
Beds
3
-
Sq. Ft.
Listing Courtesy of Corcoran, Sheri Winter Parker

Homes for Rent near Shelter Island

Neighborhoods

Cities

ZIPs

Looking for Homes For Sale?

Homes for Sale in Shelter Island
Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Terms of Service, Privacy Center, Scam Avoidance, Responsible Disclosure, Compass is an E-Verify employer, Notice for California Applicants, California COVID-19 Rules of Entry, and Your CA Privacy Rights

COMPASS, the Compass logo, and other various trademarks, logos, designs, and slogans are the registered and unregistered trademarks of Compass, Inc. dba Compass in the U.S. and/or other countries.

Corporate Responsibility, Privacy & Legal Notices: Compass is a licensed real estate broker. Compass is licensed to do business as: Compass in California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Texas, Virginia, and Washington; Compass RE in Delaware, Idaho, Pennsylvania and Tennessee; Compass Real Estate in Washington, DC, Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, and Wyoming; Compass Realty Group in Missouri and Kansas; Launch Powered by Compass in Arizona; and Compass Carolinas, LLC in South Carolina. California License # 01991628, 1527235, 1527365, 1356742, 1443761, 1997075, 1935359, 1961027, 1842987, 1869607, 1866771, 1527205, 1079009, 1272467. No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified, and Compass expressly disclaims any liability in connection therewith. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity. © Compass 2025. 212-913-9058.


Texas Real Estate Commission Information About Brokerage Services
Texas Real Estate Commission Consumer Protection Notice

New York State Fair Housing Notice
New York State Standard Operating Procedures
Notice of Reasonable Accommodations for Prospective Tenants

Compass does not discriminate against voucher holders pursuant to applicable law and all lawful sources of income are accepted.

Similar:
Greenport