Shelter Island Heights, NY Apartments & Homes for Rent

price-
1-5 of 5 Homes
a view of a house with a yard
1/11

Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Debra L. Von Brook Binder CBR

$5,000

3
Bedrooms
1,512
Square Feet
100
Acres

3 St Johns Street, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

a front view of house with a garden and trees
1/25

Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Michael Brennan

$25,000

3
Bedrooms
1,675
Square Feet
0.58
Acres

5 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964

a living room with furniture and a fireplace
1/27

Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Michael Brennan

$40,000

5
Bedrooms
4,000
Square Feet
0.69
Acres

61 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964

$75,000 | 15 Montclair Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1/35

Listing Courtesy of Corcoran, Margot Reutter

$75,000

6
Bedrooms
4,600
Square Feet
0.53
Acres

15 Montclair Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964

a view of yard with tree in front of it
1/27

Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Michael Brennan

$50,000

3
Bedrooms
3,000
Square Feet
1.87
Acres

28 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11965

For Rent:

Explore Nearby Homes

Looking for Homes For Sale?

Homes for Sale in Shelter Island Heights
Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Terms of Service, Privacy Center, Scam Avoidance, Responsible Disclosure, Compass is an E-Verify employer, Notice for California Applicants, California COVID-19 Rules of Entry, and Your CA Privacy Rights

Source: April 2025 RealTrends, Closed Residential Sales Volume 2024

COMPASS, the Compass logo, and other various trademarks, logos, designs, and slogans are the registered and unregistered trademarks of Compass, Inc. dba Compass in the U.S. and/or other countries.

Corporate Responsibility, Privacy & Legal Notices: Compass is a licensed real estate broker. Compass is licensed to do business as: Compass in Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Michigan, Mississippi, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Texas, Virginia, and Washington; Compass RE in Delaware, Idaho, Pennsylvania and Tennessee; Compass Real Estate in Washington, DC, Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, and Wyoming; Compass Realty Group in Missouri and Kansas; and Compass Carolinas, LLC in South Carolina. California License # 01991628, 1527235, 1527365, 1356742, 1443761, 1997075, 1935359, 1961027, 1842987, 1869607, 1866771, 1527205, 1079009, 1272467. No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified, and Compass expressly disclaims any liability in connection therewith. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity. © Compass 2025. 212-913-9058.


Texas Real Estate Commission Information About Brokerage Services
Texas Real Estate Commission Consumer Protection Notice

New York State Fair Housing Notice
New York State Standard Operating Procedures
Notice of Reasonable Accommodations for Prospective Tenants

Compass does not discriminate against voucher holders pursuant to applicable law and all lawful sources of income are accepted.