Mary Macaluso, Real Estate Agent

Social Media

Mary's Google Business Page

LinkedIn

Facebook

Instagram

Mary’s Concierge Page

Specialties

Buyer's Agent, Listing Agent, Notary, Property Management,

55+ Community, Commercial, Investment, New Construction,

Residential

COMPASS Standard Operating Procedures

Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more

★★★★★
"Mary Macaluso did an excellent job helping me rent one of my rentals. I am a landlord and own 6 rentals and in process of buying additional home. I've worked with many agents over the years and Mary is one of the best I've worked with. We had updates going on at rental and had aggressive schedule and Mary jumped right in and set up showings up and did an excellent presentation. We worked well together and I am a tough landlord, but Mary's common sense great professional experience made the process move along well and showing went well and house was rented in about two weeks which is impressive. Looking to sell a few rentals in the near future and I will use Mary on those sales."

★★★★★
"Mary was able to provide professional and extensive knowledge of the market that helped us secure our first home with all our needs. Throughout our open houses, and appointments, every other real estate agent made comments about Mary’s great work ethic and performance. She is well respected by all other agents and firms, proving she can go the extra step to get a deal DONE. Mary was able to introduce us to Home inspectors, attorneys, handymen, etc. that made every step of the usual gruesome home purchasing process easier. I highly recommend reaching out to Mary for your next home purchase or sale. I would personally never let friends or family go to anyone else but Mary"

★★★★★
"Mary is an excellent realtor, This was my both my husband and I first time purchasing a home and she made the process so easy and explained everything to us. Any problems that we faced she calmed us down and helped us with. I am even tell my family and friends about Mary if they ever need a realtor they need to go to with her. Thank you Mary for all your help in making us find our dream home. :)"

★★★★★
"Having Mary as our agent was the best choice we could’ve made. She helped us sell our co-op in December and helped us buy our home during these unprecedented times in a very competitive buyers market. She did this in the most smooth way possible with unwavering support throughout the entire process. Mary is professional and knowledgeable and was able to help us navigate the homebuying process from start to finish. Thank you, Mary!"

★★★★★
"Mary Macaluso is just the best. I used her as a realtor about 5 years ago when I bought my co-op. When it came time for me and my husband to start house hunting, I knew immediately that we would go straight to Mary. Mary is extremely knowledgeable in this field. She immediately makes you feel comfortable. She also looked out for our best interest! Not only that, she has a team of great people that work with you to make the process as smooth as possible! I have sent friends to Mary and they have been happy as well. I hope I never have to move again. But if I do, I know who to call!"

★★★★★
"Mary is the consummate professional. She was always prepared with industry knowledge, necessary paperwork, and an unmatched work ethic that expedited the sale of my home at an excellent price. Mary and her son John often went beyond the usual role of agent, contacting skilled contractors, attorneys, and banks on my behalf. Mary is incredibly reliable and responsive; she always made herself available to address any questions or concerns quickly, patiently, and thoughtfully. Beyond their professionalism, Mary and John are caring and wonderful people. I never felt alone during the process thanks to their constant reassuring support. I highly recommend their services to anyone buying or selling a home. Thank you Mary and John!"

★★★★★
"Mary was amazing from beginning to end! She is extremely professional and knowledgeable! This is our first time selling a house so we relied heavily on Mary. She made sure everything was in order for the sale of our house as well as for the purchase of our new home. She is also very accessible. No phone call or text goes unanswered ever. Mary’s warm, upbeat personality calmly steered us through whatever came our way to a successful end! Would highly recommend Mary and her team!!"

★★★★★
"Mary is very professional and knowledgeable. She helped me a lot all the way starting from the open house to the closing. She always responded and did what she told us she would do. She is always kept in touch whether text or phone during the whole process. Mary and the whole amazing team members, such as Gina and John, were great to work with. I greatly appreciate everything Mary and her team did. We were very pleased with the service and highly recommend them if you plan on buying or selling a home."

★★★★★
"Mary is incredible. Whether you are looking to buy or sell, she will be beside you in the process from beginning to the very end. Was always available to answer any questions and address any concerns that we had. The sale went quickly and smoothly thanks to Mary's years of experience, knowledge and commitment. She genuinely cares about her clients. We highly recommend Mary to anyone looking for a realtor."

★★★★★
"Mary was absolutely wonderful. She was honest, great communication (either in person, calls or text), helped me stay proactive in the home selling process and followed up on all my requests or concerns. I’m thrilled that I met Mary. She took me over the finish line and it’s because of her real estate expertise. I can’t say enough positive things about her. Thank you Mary. I would also like to say a big thank you to Michael, he was invaluable to my home selling experience. They make a great team."

★★★★★
"The best realtor I have ever worked with. I had the difficult task of selling my aunts home once she went to assisted living. From the first day I met Mary, she impressed me with her knowledge, professionalism and most of all her genuine sincerity. There were a lot of obstacles that came up and Mary helped us in every way. The communication between mary and I was outstanding. Didn’t have to leave several messages she was always on top of everything. I highly recommend Mary and her team to anyone that is selling or buying a home….she’s the best."

★★★★★
"Working with Mary was absolutely wonderful! She made the process seamless and always made sure she was available to assist us and answer any questions. We always felt that we had someone supporting us in this process and never alone. Mary was honest from the beginning and set realistic expectations for us, which she exceeded. We are beyond happy with the selling of our home and our new home purchase. We would use Mary again in a heartbeat. We couldn’t be more grateful for Mary and the Macaluso team."

★★★★★
"Working with Mary Macaluso Realtor and her entire Compass team brought about a wonderful result for me as the seller and I cannot recommend them highly enough. Any real estate deal needs an attentive broker and someone who will go above and beyond to make both buyer and seller satisfied. The Compass team led by Mary Macaluso Realtor is just that entity. You will never be in better hands for any of your real estate needs than with this honest and knowledgeable woman whose caring business acumen is incredible and will work for your best interest. She makes it an easy process. Thank you, Mary, for your excellent help and friendly manner—they made all the difference. Your team is a wonderful reflection of your good business ethics and practices."

★★★★★
"We had a wonderful experience working with Mary Macaluso during such a difficult time selling our parents’ home. Mary helped guide us every step of the way. It was a quick sale, and Mary brought us results that were far better than what we expected."

★★★★★
"Mary is the ultimate professional. She takes the time to get to know her clients and truly understand what they want and need in a home. I had the pleasure of working with Mary when I was looking for my home. I was a first time homebuyer at the time and had no experience with the process. Mary made what could have been an overwhelming and stressful experience much easier to navigate. She walked me through each step and reassured me throughout. To say it was a pleasure to work with her is an understatement. I would do so again in a heartbeat. I highly recommend Mary whether this is your first or fifth house!"

★★★★★
"Mary and Laine were amazing. It took over 15 months to get our house sold because of variances. Lanie helped me with all the town stuff. I would recommend this team to anyone and everyone. You will be in amazing hands with them!!"

★★★★★
"Mary is amazing!!! I never thought our moving situation would work out but Mary made it all happen seamlessly! She helped us both sell our house as well as buy our new house. She has a way of making you feel like you are her only client even though she is always very busy. She is so quick to get back to you about even the most minor question/concern and never trivializes your concerns."

★★★★★
"Mary couldn’t have been more helpful to make our selling and buying process so smooth during this time. She was so responsive to all our questions and needs while helping us through the process of selling our home and buying our new home. We used her when we bought our first home and without hesitation contacted her again for the sale and purchase of a new home. Selling and buying during this pandemic could have been extremely stressful, but Mary made it exactly the opposite. We cannot say enough good things about her work ethic, professionalism, responsiveness and genuineness. Thank you for helping us find our forever home! We love Mary and highly recommend her to help you find your forever home."

★★★★★
"We started our house search with Mary last year in 2019. We looked at many houses together and were impressed by her knowledge about details. She is very caring and keeps your best first always. She is thoroughly a professional and knows people in her trade. She helped us on every step of the way to buy our forever house. We loved working with Mary and highly recommend her!!"

★★★★★
"Mary came highly recommended from a co-worker. From the first time we met when she came to give me an appraisal I knew I was going to have her as my realtor. She was the first and only realtor I met with and knew there was no reason to have anyone else come in. She was extremely easy to work with, knowledgeable and not to mention very professional. She got us what we were looking for in our sale price within five days. I can't say enough great things about her. I highly recommend her if you need a realtor!!"

★★★★★
"Mary is the best of the best. Her knowledge, professionalism and kindness towards her clients is like no other. No matter if you're selling your home or looking to purchase one, Mary is the Realtor to work with."

★★★★★
"Mary is incredible - there’s no other way to put it! She was so helpful when buying our first home, especially during a pandemic. I don’t think anyone works harder than her! She is always available and makes you feel like a priority, regardless of how many clients she has. We feel so lucky to have worked with her, she made our new home possible! We could not recommend her more!! You won’t be sorry!"

★★★★★
"Mary was extremely professional. Tried several other agents before Mary / Compass. Mary made this experience wonderful. She was diligent. We love our new home and are very grateful that Mary was our agent."

★★★★★
"Mary is the best of the best! She truly is an amazing agent and so dedicated to her job. She was determined and would not stop until she found my husband and I our dream home. Would highly recommend!!!"

★★★★★
"Mary is by far one of the best I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. No matter where you go if you mention her name every one loves her and that should speak for itself in the business she is in. I have not only had the pleasure of working with her she become a friend to me and my family. She is compassionate professional and knowledgeable."

★★★★★
"Mary is an outstanding realtor who makes potentially stressful transactions a pleasure whether buying or selling. She is professional and always available. Highly recommend her services!"

★★★★★
"Mary is an exceptional choice if you are looking for a realtor, we highly recommend her! 5 years ago she helped us get into our starter home, and this year we returned to her to help us navigate a coordinated purchase and sale in a crazy marketplace during unprecedented times. She always kept us in mind and found us an amazing opportunity, followed by the sale of our house over one weekend that garners multiple over asking offers. She is extremely responsive, trustworthy and knowledgeable. We knew we could count on her for perspective, advice, or support on anything through the entire process. Thank you, Mary!"

★★★★★
"Mary was great from start to finish. Due to Mary’s guidance, we sold our home for way more than we expected. She was always available when we had questions or issues. When we hit a few snags with the buyers, Mary worked relentlessly to solve the problems. I highly recommend her as a realtor. We now consider her a friend!"

★★★★★
"Mary worked with us for over 2+ years helping us find the perfect home. She was very patient and was always there for us to ask questions. We finally found the right house and Mary was there every step of the way through closing. It also doesn’t hurt that she knows everyone!!! Highly recommend Mary!"

★★★★★
"Mary came to the listing appointment prepared and knowledgeable about the area where I was selling my home. She was upfront and honest about how much I would get for the property and she made herself available 24/7 after the property was listed for sale. I would 100 percent work with Mary again. She is a quality real estate agent."

★★★★★
"Mary is a rare breed. She hustles for her clients and is constantly available for any questions that come up. She actually picks up the phone! That’s such a rare thing these days. We just completed a transaction with Mary, and she made the process smooth, simple, and efficient. I never felt like I didn’t know what was going on. Her professionalism is off the charts."

★★★★★
"I used Mary Macaluso three times already. If you’re looking for someone who cares about her clients then she’s who you're looking for. I purchased my first house with her and then sold it again with her and when my buyer was having issues she stepped in and had people that helped my buyers resolve their issue which saved the sale for us. I used her again for my next purchase and after tirelessly going from house to house she found me the house I was looking for and am still in till this day. In closing, if you’re looking for a professional, loyal, caring and an all around great person, go with Mary Macaluso. You won’t be disappointed."

★★★★★
"Having Mary as our agent was the best choice we could’ve made. She helped us sell our co-op in December and helped us buy our home during these unprecedented times in a very competitive buyers market. She did this in the most smooth way possible with unwavering support throughout the entire process. Mary is professional and knowledgeable and was able to help us navigate the homebuying process from start to finish. Thank you, Mary!"

★★★★★
"We were fortunate to meet Mary Macaluso, who was actually the seller's agent and we were buyers. Her approach was professional and warm throughout without the usual high pressure gimmicks. She was crucial is getting her seller's to match our buyer's timeline on the house we were under pressure to leave based on closing dates. Mary resolved that in a way no other agent could. It was nothing short of remarkable. She is a first rate agent, who also struck us as a first rate person. Thank you Mary!!! She is a fantastic agent,the best that I have encountered, and I HIGHLY recommend her if you are searching in the area!"

★★★★★
"Mary is a knowledgeable real estate professional who gives 100% to her clients. My husband and I worked with her in Fall 2019 to sell our Islip home, and Mary was a supportive, encouraging, helpful ally in the adventure. She is an expert in the entire house selling process, responded immediately to texts and phone calls, kept us very informed about everything, addressed all questions and concerns, was excellent in communicating with the prospective buyers' realtors, was always present when she needed to be (or sent a member of her team in the rare times she was not able to be), and ultimately guided the house selling process to a wonderful conclusion with the perfect buyers. Mary cares about her clients, clearly loves her job, and her warmth shines through in every interaction. We highly recommend Mary!"

★★★★★
"Mary did a great job for us selling our house. She is very knowledgeable about the local market, is responsive, and made very helpful suggestions throughout the entire process. Her results exceeded our expectations."

★★★★★
"She is the BEST. Honest feedback, help us to make right decisions, and support all the way until you find the right house! 100% satisfaction! Thanks to her and her teammate Stacy♡"

★★★★★
"Mary is fantastic. Professional, knowledgeable and easy to work with. She has a great attitude and was responsive to all our inquires. She absolutely worked above and beyond to make sure we were informed every step of the way and that our needs were met. We highly recommend working with Mary."

★★★★★
"I’ve known Mary since since she & Roy moved into our neighbor. When it came time for me to move to Missouri, we asked Mary to sell out me house. She sold our house and got what we wanted. If your looking for a wonderful professional realtor who gets your house sold, Mary is your choice! You’ll not go wrong!"

★★★★★
"Mary could not of been more professional & helpful in helping me with the purchase of my new home. She was always accessible & most of all honest with everything. She made this a wonderful experience & would recommend her very highly to anyone."

★★★★★
"Mary was recommended to us by a very close friend. It turned out to be a great experience. Mary and her team were very professional and mindful of our needs. They communicated with us throughout the entire process and never failed to answer our questions. We would highly recommend Mary to anyone looking to sell or buy a home. Mary and her team are 5 stars in our book. -JoAnn and Richard Cavalieri."

★★★★★
"Mary is great! She made the whole process so smooth and easy! She is super professional and attentive. Any questions I had she made herself available to get me answers right away! It was a pleasure working with her! Highly recommend!"

★★★★★
"We could not have asked for a better realtor than Mary Macaluso. Not only was she professional, reliable and trustworthy, but she truly cared about getting us the house of our dreams. As never before homeowners, she was always available to answer any questions we had. She went above and beyond to make the process as painless as possible. I would recommend anyone searching for a home to reach out to Mary Macaluso."

★★★★★
"We could not have been happier with the professionalism, service, dedication and personal attention Mary Macaluso and Lainie Greenberg provided us. They were with us every step of the process from listing to closing, advocating and alleviating the stress of selling my mothers home. My mother and family are great-full we trusted Mary with her most valuable financial asset. I recommend if you are buying or selling to call Mary and Lainie."

★★★★★
"Mary was so responsive and helpful in navigating the first time home buyers process. She was thorough and knowledgeable and we are so glad we got referred to her. Thanks!!"

★★★★★
"Mary is professional and caring. Everything she said was right on the money. She made us feel comfortable and supported us through the whole process. She was extremely attentive and responsive to all of our needs. We highly recommend her!!!"

★★★★★
"We have used Mary Macaluso twice now. Once to buy our home and 10 years later to sell. Both times she has made the process as easy and stress free as possible. She is professional and friendly, and gets back to you right away. I have and will continue to refer Mary to anyone looking to buy or sell."

★★★★★
"Mary Macaluso the Real Estate agent is excellent at what she does, she is the consummate professional. Mary the person is even better! That is why you need to choose her to guide you through the buying or selling process. She brings a group of individual’s who come together to form an amazing team to work on your behalf. They outwork everyone else. Why? Simple, they enjoy what they do and it shows in the product that they put out. We were lucky to have chosen Mary, John M., Lainie G., and the entire Macaluso team to sell our house. Her team's price strategy and showings all produced a home, which sold in less than 48 hours. If you want someone who cares about just making a sale...choose someone else. If you want someone who cares about your family, your home, and her community...well then you don’t have to search any further!"

★★★★★
"Mary is by far THE best realtor on Long Island. She found us the perfect home with everything we wanted and more in this extremely competitive market. She is an absolute pleasure to work with and is incredibly professional. If anyone can help you find what you’re looking for, its this gal!"

★★★★★
"Mary's expertise and professionalism made the process of buying a home simple. Easily the best real estate agent in New York."

★★★★★
"Mary did a wonderful job in helping us find the home We were looking for plus she has a heart of gold!"

★★★★★
"Very professional and never once put us on the back burner! Always had something to show us that we asked for. I cannot thank you and your staff enough for helping us find a place to call home!!"

★★★★★
"Very Professional and easy to work with. Definitely exceeded our expectations."

★★★★★
"Excellent real estate agent."

About Mary

With over 22 years working with buyers, sellers and renters, nothing is more gratifying to Mary than seeing clients find that special place called home, except perhaps the integral, important role she plays as the real estate professional who makes it all happen. Mary offers each and every client the same level of exceptional service and consistent, transparent communication. It’s what has helped her build strong and lasting relationships with so many clients in the Long Island residential market.

Understanding the many choices with which a buyer or seller is faced, Mary hones in on the best options for each individual, then streamlines the action plan once the right scenario comes along. Her in-depth knowledge as a long-time local resident here lend to Mary’s expert ability to negotiate the best price for you in today's highly competitive market. Becoming an associate real estate broker as well as a certified buyer broker has provided her with the advanced knowledge required to sell homes faster and to represent sellers and buyers better in one of their most important life decisions. At Compass, Mary has the essential tools and technology along with access to a greater number of new homes on the market. She works hard to ensure you receive dependable, trustworthy service. She wants you to feel like family!

Driven by a genuine desire to help others, Mary has hand-picked a team of professional agents to provide her clients with constant availability and personal attention. The Macaluso team is client focused, always listening closely and taking the time necessary to understand client goals. The team has extensive market knowledge and expertise to see your purchase or sale through to a successful close.

Before becoming a Realtor®, Mary worked in the title industry from 1989-2001. The title industry gave her a strong understanding of the behind-the-scenes of the mortgage and real estate business and made it a seamless transition for her to become a Realtor®. She has been a licensed associate broker since 2001.

Born and raised in upstate New York, Mary has called Bethpage home since 1981, Mary and her husband Roy, they have three grown children, Sara, John, and Victoria, and five grandchildren. Mary is also active in local community events and is currently serving on the Board of Directors of the Bethpage Public Library since 2015.

Mary looks forward to sharing her experience with you throughout the selling and or buying process.