Kaitlynn McCartney

We met Kaitlyn a little over two years ago at an open house, and I instantly knew she was someone we could work with. We were just beginning our search and felt hesitant about selling our home and buying a new one. Kaitlyn was incredibly patient, checking in every couple of months and reaching out whenever a home came on the market that she thought we would love. She never pressured us and was ready when we were. Kaitlyn truly listened to what we wanted. My husband had very specific must-haves for our forever home, and she respected those priorities, only showing us homes that matched our needs. When we finally found our dream home in Massapequa Park, she did everything she could to make the buying experience as smooth as possible. We always felt she had our backs. She brought that same care and attention to selling our home in Merrick. She offered staging advice and was there during the photography appointment, helping move things around to make sure the pictures came out beautifully. She was always respectful of our space and time when coordinating showings and our open house. When we received several offers, she patiently helped us weigh our options and choose the best one for us. Kaitlyn also helped negotiate our purchase and coordinated with the seller’s agent, attorneys, and inspector. From recommending movers to being there at closing, she supported us every step of the way. I wholeheartedly recommend Kaitlyn to anyone looking to buy, sell, or do both. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience, and we can’t wait to invite her over once we’ve finished making our new house our home. Thank you, Kaitlyn, for helping us find our forever home! Kristi Stuckey

We cannot recommend Kaitlynn enough! As first-time homebuyers in Oceanside, New York, we feel incredibly lucky to have had her by our side throughout the entire process. Buying our first home can feel overwhelming, but Kaitlynn went above and beyond in every possible way to make the experience smooth, exciting, and memorable. From the very beginning, Kaitlynn was honest and transparent with us while we were looking at homes. She always gave us her genuine opinion about whether she thought a property would be a good fit for us, and she ultimately helped us find the home we fell in love with and purchased! Throughout the entire process, she made sure we always had access to the house, even for the smallest things, like getting in to measure something. She explained every step clearly, kept us informed, and was always incredibly responsive. There was never a time when we felt we couldn’t reach her or that our questions were a bother. Even when we had questions about things outside her specific role, she was always someone we felt comfortable turning to for guidance. What made Kaitlynn truly special was how much she cared about making this experience meaningful for us. When our offer was accepted, she surprised us with chocolate-covered strawberries, and after closing, she gave us the most thoughtful gift for our future kitchen. Those little touches made such a big difference and showed how genuinely invested she was in our happiness. Her communication and care didn’t stop at closing, either. She continued checking in to make sure we were happy with everything and settling into this exciting new chapter. We are so grateful that Kaitlynn was part of our first home-buying journey. She made us feel supported, informed, and excited every step of the way, and we truly couldn’t have asked for a better person to guide us through such an important milestone. We would recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. If you’re looking for someone who is knowledgeable, responsive, honest, thoughtful, and genuinely goes above and beyond for her clients, Kaitlynn is the person you want in your corner! Brianna Serra

Kaitlyn did a great job helping us sell our home in Massapequa Park! She was very attentive to our needs and the house sold quickly for a good price. Liz Girardi Schoen

Kaitlynn was referred to us by our agent on the purchase side to help us sell our first home in Baldwin, and we were so thrilled that she was from the first time she stepped into our home. Working with her was seamless from start to finish. She made herself available whenever it worked for us and was always just a phone call or text away—no matter the time of day or how many times a day! She made what could have been a stressful and emotional process feel easy and comfortable. I would highly recommend Kaitlynn to anyone buying or selling in the area. I can guarantee that you’ll walk away from your transaction not only feeling like you got the very best out of your deal, but with a friend, too. Even our 3-year-old son still asks about her! Thank you, Kaitlynn, for everything! We are so grateful to have had you by our side! Brittany C

I can’t say enough great things about Kaitlyn McCarthy! She helped me purchase my home in Massapequa and she was absolutely incredible throughout the entire process. We looked at several homes and went through multiple competitive wars, but Caitlin never gave up on helping me find the right one. She was very patient, responsive, knowledgeable, and always gave me honest and value advice. Her experience and expertise in the Long Island real estate market made a huge difference, especially when it came to putting together competitive offers and navigating the home buying process. Kaitlynn truly went above and beyond for me and thanks to her dedication and persistence. I was able to secure the perfect home. If you’re looking to buy a home in Long Island and want a realtor, who’s knowledgeable, very professional, very dedicated, and genuinely cares about her clients. I highly recommend Kaitlynn. I couldn’t be happier with my experience and I am extremely grateful for everything she did to help me become a homeowner! Thank you for everything, Kaitlynn!! 🫡 Joel Bolivar

Kaitlynn was patient with us throughout this whole journey and brought a wealth of knowledge and guidance! 100% would recommend again and again. Shannon Carlisi

Kaitlynn is an exceptional real estate agent. She is extremely knowledgeable, professional and personable. She was always available and responsive from the time she listed our home until the closing. Kaitlynn is a perfect 10! Susan Bendex

Working with Kaitlynn was an amazing experience from start to finish. We purchased our home in Merrick Woods, and her knowledge of the neighborhood was invaluable. Since she lives here herself, she truly understands the community and helped us feel confident every step of the way. What really sets Kaitlynn apart is that she genuinely loves what she does, and it shows. She is professional, responsive, honest, and always had our best interests at heart. We felt completely confident having her represent us, and she handled every part of the process with class and professionalism. We couldn’t be happier with our experience and highly recommend Kaitlynn to anyone looking to buy or sell a home! Thank you Kaitlynn for all that you did for us. - Mike & Michelle Kraus

Kaitlynn is the absolute best realtor. As first-time buyers going through a successful bidding war, and not even being the highest bidder, we could not have asked for anyone better in our corner! We spoke with so many realtors, and no one was even remotely as knowledgeable, respectful, comforting and professional as Kaitlynn, especially in the Merrick Woods area. Ultimately where her knowledge and expertise helped us successfully buy our home. She was always there to help, constantly checked in, and was incredibly diligent throughout the entire process which took sometime given the market but an absolute true professional. She kept us sane, guided us seamlessly through every step, and ultimately helped us secure our dream home. We are beyond grateful. At this point, I honestly do not know how she has any competition. She is 100/10, wouldn't look anywhere else!- Vincent Banker

For the past two years, Kaitlyn has been right by my side, patient, honest, encouraging, and never once giving up on finding me exactly what I wanted. As a single homeowner, this journey meant everything to me, and Kaitlyn and her team truly made the dream possible. From start to finish, every person she recommended was professional, knowledgeable, and made the entire process feel smooth and manageable. I never felt alone, overwhelmed, or unsure, I felt supported every step of the way. This wasn’t just about buying a home. It was about trust, consistency, and having someone who genuinely cared about my vision and my future. I’m beyond thankful and couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Even till this day she checks up on me to see how everything is going which just shows how committed she is to her clients. Forever grateful !- Ashley Louimarre Donovan

We were first time home buyers, Kaitlynn was so patient with us we took almost a full year to find the right house in east rockaway and I know she would have kept showing us houses for another year if we needed it!- Sean Donovan

We had an amazing experience working with Kaitlynn, especially as first-time home buyers. She was incredibly attentive, knowledgeable, and patient throughout the entire process. In such a competitive and popular area like Massapequa, having someone so responsive and proactive made all the difference. Kaitlynn took the time to explain every step, answered all of our questions, and truly had our best interests in mind. We always felt supported and confident knowing she was on our side. We couldn’t recommend her more highly!- Brandon DeStasio

As first-time home buyers, we truly hit the jackpot with Kaitlynn. Her expertise in the Massapequa market, constant communication, and unwavering support made the entire process unbelievably smooth. She went above and beyond to understand our needs, advocate for us, and help us secure a home we love. She made the home buying experience actually enjoyable! We couldn’t imagine going through this with anyone else. We recommend her more highly than words can express—an absolute standout in real estate!- Caitlyn Wrynn

Outstanding Experience from Start to Finish! Working with Kaitlynn was an absolute pleasure! As first time buyers, she demonstrated professionalism, exceptional market knowledge, and genuine care for our needs. Kaitlynn was always available to answer questions, provided honest guidance, and went above & beyond to ensure a smooth process. We felt supported every step of the way. Our dream was to buy our first home in Bellmore, and Kaitlynn made it happen! If you're looking for a dedicated, trustworthy, and results-driven realtor, look no further. Highly recommend!- Bianca Velotti

Kaitlynn McCartney is excellent realtor. She helped us extremely and was just amazing. She just sold my home in merrick woods that was previously listed with another agent twice for over the asking price. I highly recommend Kaitlynn😊- Patricia Pistone

I am writing this review on behalf of my mother. Kaitlynn was a huge help to us not only in selling our family home but also working with my mom in a professional, courteous and kind manner in helping her find a new apartment after being in the same home for over 30 years. I would highly recommend her for any buying or selling real estate needs.- Nick Spadafora

Kaitlynn was amazing! She helped my husband and I purchase our first home in Nassau County. As first time home buyers we were so unsure of everything and she really took the time to explain everything to us in great detail. 10/10 would 100% reccomend Kaitlynn to anyone looking to buy or sell in Nassau County. Not only was she super helpful and extremely patient with us she knew Nassau like the back of her hand. Extremely thorough and knowledgeable, so if you’re like us and don’t know the process she will for sure be able to walk you through it. Truly cannot say enough good things about her.- Steph Cee

Kaitlynn was an absolute pleasure to deal with. Knowledge and driven, she cares about what she does and how she does it. Kaitlynn sold my house of 21 years in Nassau County. She was always available to answer any questions and always with a big smile. She has a great energy about her. She’s fantastic!- Rosana Gonzalez

Kaitlynn McCartney is the best real estate agent! As first time buyers, we were new to the process and Kait was so helpful & walked us through everything. She is such a thorough and reliable agent and made the process easy & enjoyable. We bought in Massapequa and are so happy with the house she helped us find & purchase! Highly recommend!- Brianne Bombara

My husband and I just sold our first home and bought our forever home located in merrick , all thanks to Kaitlynn ! She made the sale and purchase seamless . She is seriously such a powerhouse in the real estate world . Her dedication and determination to get deals done are unmatched . She truly cares and nurtures every single deal in her path . Whoever has the chance to work with her is extremely lucky! We can’t recommend her enough !- Roseanne Inzerilla

First time home buyer and despite being a back up offer Kaitlynn helped us get the deal. The entire process was seamless, Kaitlynn was a pleasure to work with!- Denis Clark

Kaitlynn helped us with the purchase of our first home. From the start, she was incredibly informative and always available to answer any of the questions my husband or I had about the home buying process. She was proactive and on top of the offer we made. Despite, being a backup offer, Kaitlynn stayed on it and helped us secure the home for our family. She is both very professional and super friendly. We would highly recommend working with Kaitlynn. She was the best!- Emily Clark

Our realtor, Kaitlynn was terrific! She got to work immediately on our listing and never let up until we had a full price offer. Even after that, she checked up on us and helped out with closing details through the final weeks of the sale. Whatever she could do, she did! I can’t recommend her enough!!!- Barbara McCamish

Kaitlynn provided my family and I with an amazing experience finding our forever home, and selling our starter home. She had a team of experts who, along with her expertise and skill set, could not have created a better experience for us. I would recommend Kaitlyn to anyone looking for a smart, knowledgeable, personable and authentic agent who will advocate for you during the entire process.- Gina Sartori

Outstanding Experience from Start to Finish! Working with Kaitlynn was an absolute pleasure! As first time buyers, she demonstrated professionalism, exceptional market knowledge, and genuine care for our needs. Kaitlynn was always available to answer questions, provided honest guidance, and went above & beyond to ensure a smooth process. We felt supported every step of the way. Our dream was to buy our first home in Bellmore, and Kaitlynn made it happen! If you're looking for a dedicated, trustworthy, and results-driven realtor, look no further. Highly recommend!- Bianca Cipriano

Kaitlynn was absolutely amazing! As first time home buyers, she guided us every step of the way and supported us through all our decision making. She is extremely knowledgeable and experienced and was very patient with us as we navigated through the home buying process. We are so grateful that we heard about Kaitlynn and we would 10000% recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home !!- Kristin McDonough

As first-time home buyers, we were nervous and overwhelmed by the process but Kaitlynn walked us through every step with patience, clarity, and care. Her expertise and calm demeanor made all the difference, and thanks to her, we found our dream home in Merrick. We felt supported from start to finish, and we’re so grateful for her dedication. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and compassionate agent! - Samantha Winakor Bigel

We recently had the absolute pleasure of working with Kaitlynn as she helped us find our dream home! Throughout the whole process Kaitlynn was responsive, honest, straightforward and always kind- qualities that are tough to come by in real estate these days. She was there for us in the early stages of house hunting when we weren't exactly certain of what we were looking for. She eventually introduced us to our dream home- an off market property that we never would have seen had we not been working with Kaitlynn! She is truly amazing at what she does and we could not thank her enough for helping us through the entire house hunting process! - Kaitlin McLaughlin

My husband and I recently worked with Kaitlynn when purchasing our new home! Her attention to detail, amazing communication, and warm, caring personality are only a few of the reasons why we love her. She gave us white glove service every step of the way. If you’re looking for the best in the business, look no further! - Danielle Cruz

Kait is great! She was patient, listened to our needs, and gave us professional advice that ultimately landed us in the perfect home. Her team (attorney, inspector, mortgage broker) were all exceptional and made the transaction streamlined and simple. Highly recommended! - Michael Beasly