Amanda McAvena's Profile Photo

Amanda McAvena

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
About Amanda
Amanda has called Brooklyn home for over a decade living in Williamsburg and settling in Park Slope where she first purchased a co-op and served on the board. Before joining Compass, Amanda worked in the advertising industry on Fortune 100 brands and applies the same strategies and marketing principles to the properties she represents. In 2023 she was ranked by the WSJ as the top 20 agent in Brooklyn and is part of a select group of 1.5% of agents nationally in terms of sales volume. 

As a principal agent at Compass Amanda has been responsible for over $100M in sales. This volume of transactions provides keen insight into what is happening in the market allowing her to guide clients on shifts and opportunities. Originally from Minnesota, Amanda has a true appreciation for Prospect Park and the historic Brownstones in Brooklyn. She is actively involved in the Park Slope Civic Council where she co-chairs the annual Food For Thought event to raise money for college scholarships.

Amanda has a passion for the construction and renovating process and is currently working on renovating and restoring a historic house. This experience allows her to offer her clients insight into the construction process for large and small projects. She loves helping buyers and sellers understand what updates will add the most value to a home and how to transform a space. She currently lives in Park Slope with her husband and two daughters. 


A pair of scissors hanging from a wire


Client Testimonials
Scroll down for more

Amanda saw us through thick and thin all the way to ownership. We were first time buyers looking for a unique space -- Amanda listened to our goals and worked to make them happen, rather than trying to redirect us to what the market offered or what other clients wanted. She was patient and not pushy as we passed on several "nice but not us" properties. Amanda found our eventual home through off-market channels and helped us put together a competitive offer before the property was listed.
We're thrilled with our new home.

- Sophie and Derek

"Amanda helped us make small but important staging decisions--and made it super easy by picking out items -- that ultimately led to the sale of our apartment! We have tried to sell months earlier and were unsuccessful but Amanda had a vision and helped us make it happen. Then she pulled off a slight miracle in Brooklyn real estate: negotiated our purchase of a new place contingent on our sale! We're now in our dream home and it is truly thanks to Amanda and her know-how, dedication, and relationships in the field. She went above and beyond and held our hands through the ups and downs of buying and selling in Brooklyn. Highly highly recommend her!"  

- Tamara D.

"Amanda was the consummate representative. She walked me through renovating and then selling my apartment -- a process I'd been DREADING -- with ease and clarity. I was astonished at how effortless it was. Or at how effortless she made it all feel. On the buying end, she was always responsive, happy to talk, and full of advice. No matter how many places came and went and how many bids we lost or decisions we made, Amanda never pushed or cajoled. She allowed us to work at our own pace and was always there for us. From beginning to end, she was no-fuss, honest, helpful, and approachable. She was perfect." 

- Richard H.

"Amanda is a trusted advisor when it comes to any real estate-related questions. She is highly professional, resourceful and very pleasant to work with. Amanda understood our investment needs and managed to source deals with insightful market knowledge. She stayed actively involved throughout the deal negotiation, execution as well as the seamless transformation into a highly sought after apartment." 

- Rose & Jimmy

"Amanda helped us find the perfect apartment in Brooklyn and we couldn't speak more highly of her. It was our first purchase and she was always there for us, and help to answer the myriad of questions we had and guided us through the daunting process of buying a place in NY. Amanda has it all. She is competent, friendly, communicative, honest, and we were incredibly lucky to work with her." 

- Leo and Morgan

"Amanda sets a high bar for professionalism and integrity that attracts dream tenants of equal caliber. Smart, generous and conscientious, Amanda is truly a gem among realtors — we will not work with anyone else!" 

- Quito & Elizabeth

"Before we officially started our search for our first home, we heard plenty of scary stories, but Amanda showed us we had nothing to fear. From our first meeting with her, Amanda was supportive, patient, kind and knowledgeable. She helped us search through open houses to find our dream place, never pushing us to make a decision we weren't comfortable with. We cannot recommend her enough." 

- Richie and Kelli

"Amanda was fantastic to work with in selling our apartment. Ultimately we were able to sell our apartment for 11% more than our original goal, and Amanda got us through contract signing and closing flawlessly while we were out of the country for two months. We really enjoyed our time working with Amanda and will be suggesting her to anyone we know buying or selling!" 

- Mark & Taylor

"Amanda helped manage a complicated 1031 exchange and found a great 4 family townhouse and a 2 bedroom condominium--along with excellent tenants for me. She was patient, focused, professional and a genuinely great person. Purchasing properties in a highly competitive market is never easy but I think it would be hard to find a better agent." 

-Carl M.

"Amanda McAvena is a practiced and knowledgeable agent, highly ethical and professional and able to beautifully balance the human and business aspects or real estate. Amanda has great marketing and design sensibilities, is active in her Brooklyn community, and values the rich legacy of buildings in Brooklyn. We have used Amanda’s services to both sell and rent property and can’t recommend anyone more highly." 

-Mona and Henry


Amanda McAvena’s Listings

$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
$899,000 | 133 8th Avenue, Unit 2E | Park Slope
1/13
Listed By CompassContract Signed

$899,000

Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
1
Square Feet
Unavailable
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
$835,000 | 75 Henry Street, Unit 11L | Brooklyn Heights
1/13
Listed By CompassContract Signed

$835,000

Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
1
Square Feet
Unavailable